Undecided - 04-26-2018 | Clear Admit DecisionWire

<< Back to DecisionWire

April 26, 2018 1:15pm ET

Enrolled: Undecided

Admitted: U. Chicago Booth , Columbia

Applied: U. Chicago Booth, Columbia

Entering Year: 2020

Post MBA Career: Asset Management, inc. Hedge Funds Companies: Blackrock, Fidelity, Vanguard, Other

GMAT: 770

Notes:

So torn. Loved students at both the schools. Very strong preference to be in NYC after school, been here my whole life. Booth: Pros- Better Brand/Ranking. Broader Approach to Inv. Mgmt, Personally a better fit. Cons- Not in NYC. CBS: Pros- NYC (where I have a network in the industry).

Like (0)

Show Comments (7) Last: May 3, 2018

anon89804 Likes Earned: 0 Assuming 2018 entry? Very tough indeed given fit vs preference. Would say coin toss really (0)

anon16339 Likes Earned: 0 Did you got an extension to decide from Booth? Deposit was due yesterday. (0)

anon14320 Likes Earned: 1 Sorry but CBS's Value Investing Program is seriously unparalleled with almost 100% placement. Rankings change all the time and I'm not sure Booth actually does have a better brand, especially when Columbia is more internationally recognized. I feel almost everyone in Chicago has a Booth MBA degree (from part-time, evening, weekend programs) while you'll actually have a huge network in NYC after school. (0)

anon11276 Likes Earned: 0 If it helps your decision, I currently work at a sovereign wealth fund and did not apply to Chicago (Harvard Wharton and Columbia only). Chicago and Columbia have very similar placement in Private Equity, but Columbia has a very clear advantage for Hedge Funds and Real Estate (0)

anon32276 Likes Earned: 6 I'm in the process of making the same decision and pretty sure I'm going to Columbia. It's definitely a difficult decision, and I feel like I'd be happy at either one (although I did feel a better fit at Booth), but if you for sure want to be in NY, then CBS may be the way to go here. (0)

anon16303 Likes Earned: 0 I would probably go with Booth here. You can easily get NYC from Booth plus it opens more doors in other places. Also there is a perception that Columbia is kind of in decline while Booth is very much on the upswing. (0)

anon11276 Likes Earned: 0 CBS has a $500M building to be delivered in 2 years. If anything is in systematic decline I would say it is the city of Chicago, not Columbia. Regarding relative strengths, it is pretty much common knowledge that Columbia has a stronger brand internationally and in NY, while Booth has a stronger brand in the rest of the US. In my view, considering the OP's target industry, CBS is indisputably a better option. Regardless of my personal views, I would recommend OP to have a careful look at both employment reports. (0)